NAMI's Pharma Funders - Serial Off-label Promoter Astrazeneca Tops the List

The National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) until recently was reluctant to reveal the source of its funding. But thanks to Sen. Grassley we now can learn NAMI's sources for Major Foundation and Corporate Support, which you can find here.

I downloaded the list of "funders" for 2009. Fortunately, unlike pharmaceutical companies who have revealed monies paid to physicians (see, for example, "Transparency Vs. Translucency in Reporting Physician Payments"), NAMI's numbers are easy to copy into Excel spreadsheets and analyze.

In 2009, NAMI received 84 payments over $5,000 from different sources. Payments total $4,737,610.00 of which $3,836,750.00 (81%) came from major pharmaceutical companies. The following pie chart shows how the $3,836,750.00 was divided among major pharma funders (click on the chart for an enlarged view).

The biggest pharma funder in 2009 was AstraZenca (AZ), which donated $1,255,000.00. Recall that AZ is forced to pay about 400X that amount ($520 million) to resolve allegations that it illegally marketed the anti-psychotic drug Seroquel for uses not approved as safe and effective by the Food and Drug Administration (see HHS press release here). I guess you might say AZ got a large NEGATIVE ROI for its NAMI investment!

Lilly was next on the list having donated $750,500.00 to NAMI in 2009. Recall that Lilly markets Cymbalta and that it recently received a warning letter from the FDA about misleading a Cymablta print ad -- ie, re: "omission of risk information." Cymbalta is indicated for treatment of depression among many other things these days (see "The Cymbalta Buzz Machine is at Full Throttle!").

The third biggest NAMI pharma "funder" for 2009 was BMS, which donated $506,250.00. Recall that BMS markets the drug Abilify for bipolar disorder. Some time ago, Andy Behrman -- BMS's patient spokesperson for Abilify -- went on a campaign against the very product he endorsed for money (see "Andy Behrman, Now an Anti-BMS Spokesperson, Says 'Ask Your Doctor If Abilify is Wrong for You'").

It's a crazy, crazy world out there in the marketing of mental illness drugs!

How NOT to Solicit Adverse Medical Event Reports

My Twitter and real-life pal Fabio Gratton (@skypen) -- Co-founder & Chief Innovation Officer of Ignite Health -- sent out this tweet today:
New Web Site Invites Patients To Report on Adverse Medical Events: http://bit.ly/bp7EGx #fdasm #hcsm
Where Fabio tweets, I follow!

So I clicked on the link and found this article:
The Empowered Patient Coalition and Consumers Union's Safe Patient Project have launched a Web site that invites patients to fill out a 40-question survey about their experiences with an adverse medical event, Modern Healthcare reports.

The survey asks respondents to provide details on the incident, such as:

* The state where the error occurred;
* The type of health care provider involved;
* The procedure or treatment associated with the incident;
* Factors contributing to the error;
* Whether the affected patient considered legal action; and
* How the health care provider responded to the incident.

Patients have the option of submitting the survey anonymously.

The coalition said it plans to aggregate the information and use it to identify patterns that could lead to adverse medical events.
At first, I thought this survey was the one developed by Dr. Basch mentioned in my previous post: "If Patients Know Best, then Patient Social Networks Can Help Capture and Report AEs". Not the case. The article linked to this Empowered Patient Coalition web page.

I wanted to fill out the survey, but it quickly dawned on me that I had better things to do with my life than to wade through a Survey Monkey survey consisting of 43 (not 40) questions, many of them open ended.

This survey is no easier than the FDA's MedWatch Voluntary Reporting Form.

I don't see very many patients filling out the Empowered Patient Coalition form, which is too bad because I believe in the Coalition's cause: "We want the public to know that they can and must be the cornerstone to improving health care quality and safety and that their experiences are being counted. Sharing your story will ensure that your experiences will assist us in collecting data to be used to identify the sources of medical harm and to look for ways to keep patients safe in the future."

As far as "sharing stories" goes, patients are already doing that on sites like PatientsLikeMe, which can be mined for adverse events as I discussed here.

Social Media and the Future of Adverse Event Reporting

I am speaking tomorrow at the World Drug Safety Congress in Washington, DC. The title of my presentation is "Social Media and the Future of Adverse Event Reporting." You can view the presentation here:

Pharma's ObamaCare Math: It All Adds Up, But...

Drug companies are already claiming a loss of income due to costs related to the new U.S. health-care overhaul (aka, "ObamaCare"). First, Lilly claimed costs associated with higher rebates to the Medicaid government health program for the poor, etc. will reduce its 2010 revenue by $350 million to $400 million. Then, Johnson & Johnson said its 2010 revenue would be cut between $400 million and $500 million (see "Pharma Sales Set to Grow 5%-8%; Overhaul Effects Unclear").

It seems that the top 20 pharma companies got together and decided how to divvy up the $80 Bn that Billy Tauzin promised the drug industry would kick in to help pay for health care reform over 10 years. If each of these 20 companies claim losses of about $400 million per year for ten years, it all adds up to -- you guessed it: $80 billion!

Not included in these calculations is the 5%-8% annual increase in global pharmaceutical sales over the next five years predicted by IMS Health, which also predicted that the health system overhaul may “spur fundamental change in the market” [due to new sales of drugs to previously uninsured Americans] starting 5 years from now.