Pfizer's Facebook Fiasco: Chapstick Slapstick Ad Uses Woman's Ass as a Prop

The AdWeek article "ChapStick Gets Itself in a Social Media Death Spiral" caught my attention yesterday. It describes how Pfizer mishandled negative comments about a Chapstick ad image posted on its Chapstick Facebook page. Here's the play-by-play of the "death spiral" as reported by AdWeek:

"ChapStick posts weird image on Facebook of a woman, ass in the air [see photo at left], looking for her ChapStick behind a couch. Blogger is disgusted, blogs about it. Blogger tries to reply on Facebook too. ChapStick deletes her comments. Others object to the image. ChapStick deletes their comments. ChapStick's ads with the line "Be heard at Facebook.com/ChapStick" start to look foolish. People keep commenting. ChapStick keeps deleting. People get angry. ChapStick gets worried. The image isn't even that big of a deal—it's ChapStick's reaction to the criticism that galls. 'What asses,' people say of ChapStick (get it?). People start commenting about why they can't see their old comments. ChapStick can't keep up with all the deleting. Comments are getting through, and they're nasty."

Eventually, Pfizer apologized (sort of). The official Pfizer Twitter account (@pfizer_news) said: "The ChapStick ad was not intended to offend anyone & we R pulling it ASAP. Thank you to our ChapStick fans for providing this feedback". It also apologized on Facebook:
"We see that not everyone likes our new ad, and please know that we certainly didn't mean to offend anyone!" the post says. "Our fans and their voices are at the heart of our new advertising campaign, but we know we don't always get it right. We've removed the image and will share a newer ad with our fans soon!"
But then, says AdWeek, there's this "very strange" second paragraph: "We apologize that fans have felt like their posts are being deleted and while we never intend to pull anyone's comments off our wall, we do comply with Facebook guidelines and remove posts that use foul language, have repetitive messaging, those that are considered spam-like (multiple posts from a person within a short period of time) and are menacing to fans and employees."

I emphasized "have repetitive messaging" and "those that are considered spam-like." "Repetitive" and "spam-like" are pretty subjective terms that can be interpreted differently by different people. I wonder if this comment moderation policy can be found in Pfizer's secretive social media "playbook" (for more on that, see here).

Obviously, this moderation policy can be used selectively to allow only positive posts such as these "repetitive" messages currently found on Chapstick's FB page: "I ALWAYS have Chapstick with me everywhere I go.", "ChapStick is an everday part of me:)", "Chapstick and my lips are bffs.", "i always have one in my pocket!", "I LOVE CHAP STICK".

But it's not Pfizer's moderation policy that Chapstick consumers originally complained about. It's the image of a "woman, ass in the air" that compelled this sort of comment:
"Have we really become so desensitized as women that we just ACCEPT that our bodies are used as props to sell products? That women in sexually suggestive poses and naked women (google "Chapstick and Amanda Ware") are being used to sell LIP BALM? That we just look the other way and say "eh, what's the problem?" There is a problem. A big one. By sitting on the sidelines and being ok with such images, you essentially give a thumbs up to the overt sexualization of women in the media. Look around. Pay attention. If that was your daughter's rear end showcased for all the world to see, how would you feel about it? -- Tasha Burwinkle Murphy (Redmond, WA)."
Of course, not all women commenters agree:
"People have too much time on their hands if they are worried (and harassing) a company for a silly ad like this. There is NOTHING offensive about it, unless someone is looking to make something offensive out of it." -- Nicole Leigh (Chalfont, PA)
There's a long-standing tradition of using women in ads -- including most direct-to-consumer (DTC) Rx drug ads. I've pointed this out many times here on Pharma Marketing Blog (most recently here and here). Until social media, however, women haven't been able to submit comments directly to advertisers about offensive ads. And women are VERY important when it comes to social media marketing and communications.

Women and Social Media
According to a Pew Research Center Internet & American Life Project survey (see here), "Young adult women ages 18-29 are the power users of social networking; fully 89% of those who are online use the sites overall and 69% do so on an average day. Looking more closely at gender differences, women have been significantly more likely to use social networking sites than men since 2009' (see chart below).


PEW SM Survey Gender Data


How can marketers better communicate with women via social media? That's a topic that I will explore in an upcoming Pharma Marketing Talk LIVE podcast: "How to Score With Women (as a Marketer) via Social Media." I invite you to participate and/or listen live or listen to the podcast archive afterward (here). You can also participate in the ongoing Twitter discussion using the hash tag #SMXFactor.

72 comments:

Unknown said...

Hi! I found a really good agency that offers online protection solutions! The company is Onsist® and you can see everything that they are offering on their website!

Unknown said...

Regulus Films is a professional video production company that works with some of the Best videographers in the industry to provided you with a level of production that easily surpass any of our competitors. Regulus can work with any budget and strive for 100% satafaction.

Unknown said...

Hello there!
If you want to find the best copyright protection company i think this is the right place for you: https://www.onsist.com . These guys are based in 2010 in Netherlands and help companies protect their copyrighted content material in opposition to illegal copying, selling and distributin

davidsmith said...

I guide the students that how they can pass the exams and how can they get the certification for the latest knowledge this certification exam students click at JN0-1301 Exam dumps or visit its certification its better for your bright future and will helpful to attain the IT certification 

Joseph Smith said...

The course materials are absolutely excellent, and the presenters strike the right balance between providing technical detail and easy to comprehend and digest information about the Cisco Business Architecture Practitioner Practice Exam Questions.

donaldfackler said...

Get valid and latest Citrix 1Y0-203 exam dumps with competitive price. our CertificationGenie gives you the questions and answers are available in two easy formats, PDF and Practice software

Steven Jacob said...

Certification Coaching is a platform where certified professional participate in discussions and help people to successfully pass thier exams for certification.

certshero said...

i have passed the cisco 200-901 exam by using certshero.com

Dumpshq said...

i have pass the cisco 200-901 exam in first attempt, i suggest you to visit this site ,just for sharing my exprience.

Anonymous said...

If you interested in website develpment in lahore then For best website development at best price please visit our website.

Kalesh said...

I found a lot of useful information from CertsDeals about real exam topics. It is indeed a useful source of preparation for DCA Questions.

Harsh said...

Increase your success rate in Exam through DCA Dumps. Best Opportunity for you.

Harsh said...

I have pass the DCA Dumps. I suggested u visit the website.

Dumpshq said...

I succeeded in Isaca Cisa Exam with the help of this study material. My experience says Cisa Dumps are definately valid and effective.

Jacky Jonas said...

Best Opportunity for you to get IT Certification MS-100 dumps

Harsh said...

I found a lot of useful information from CertsDeals about real exam topics. My experience says Actual MS-100 Questions are definately valid and effective.

Harsh said...

I have pass Actual MS-500 Questions. I suggest u visit the website.

Cisa Dumps said...

Journey of using dumpshq was amazing. Most of its practice questions actually appeared in the real exam. I recommend Cism Dumps of dumpshq

Harsh said...

We Offer real and updated Microsoft MS-500 Questions for Microsoft 365 Security Administration exam. Our Microsoft MS-500 exam dumps prepared by experienced and Microsoft experts.

Watson said...

CertificationsSoul Splunk SPLK-1002 Exam Questions

It would be ideal if you click on the web link to get more insights about Splunk SPLK-1002 Exam Questions . 

Coupon code: SAVE20

Making it through Splunk Core Certified Power User Exam is the most difficult task.Splunk SPLK-1002 questions are inclined to prompt via the Splunk Core Certified Power User Questions as well as find their skills valid with appropriate amount of effort.

Unknown said...

The reason I am recommending Dumpshq PMP Dumps is because that I succeeded in PMI PMP Exam with the help of this study material. My experience says dumpshq PMP Dumps are definately valid and effective.

Dumpshq said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Jacky Jonas said...

CertificationGenie is offers updated Microsoft MS-900 dumps pdf questions for Microsoft 365 Fundamentals exam. Most of the people want to pass the Microsoft MS-900 exam and I recommend they should use Microsoft MS-900 Questions for better exam preparation.

Unknown said...

I prepared SAP-C01 dumps PDF questions and they were easy to use on smartphone and laptop.

Unknown said...

Examstrainer is offering latest Microsoft AZ-900 exam questions for Microsoft Azure Fundamentals certification which is famous now a days. ExamTrainer’s Microsoft AZ-900 Dumps or prep material has all proven strategies along with various practice tests to clear your final Microsoft Azure Fundamentals exam just in your first Attempt.

Isabell Kiral said...

This is very nice photo and many people like it because it is very attractive and its quality is very nice and amazing. People like such kind of photos and get inspiration. Cheap dissertation writing service.

Deandarren said...

300-715 Questions

Nazir Writes said...

So impressive ANS-C00 Dumps

warsh dean said...

This is great material. tent in a backpack

Unknown said...

I was panicking but thanks to DumpshQ that removed my worries. 200-901 dumps PDF questions were easy to prepare and they got all the information I needed to answer real exam questions.

Unknown said...

I was panicking but AZ-304 dumps that removed my worries. DumpshQ AZ-304 PDF questions were easy to prepare and they got all the information I needed to answer real exam questions.

smithjohns said...

If you are finding material to prepare for AZ-204 exam. you have to prepare with AZ-204 dumps.

Mack Jones said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mack Jones said...

DumpsSchool provide you to get updated Microsoft DA-100 Dumps PDF questions answers and with the help of them you can pass in your First Attempt.

Deandarren said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Deandarren said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Deandarren said...

If you are planning to appear in 200-901 exam and are searching for a suitable study material then there is no better option than 200-901 Dumps. Examstrainer provide you to get Valid & Real Cisco 200-901 Dumps to pass the 200-901 exam in first Try.

Unknown said...

If you are worried about your tests don't be scared of them. We are here to give you fundamental Microsoft AZ-303 Exam dumps . It's definitely not hard to use. There's no better strategy to effectively prepare other than using authentic Microsoft AZ-303 requests gave by us. We promise you that is really helpful and easy to use. You can without a very remarkable stretch benefit of it by downloading it ensuing to purchasing or furthermore buy a PDF report for questions and answers. AZ-303 test dump is quite a nice material.

Dumpshq said...

Do you have a plan to verify your skills, knowledge and experience with the help of SAA-C02 Certification exam? Looking for simple, smart and swift that can ace your SAA-C02 preparation and enables you to pass the final SAA-C02 certification exam with good scores? If your answer is yes then just calm down and checkout the best features of DumpsHQ SAA-C02 dumps that are designed by experienced and certified SAA-C02 professional after deep research.

Mack Jones said...

At the start, I was very much worried regards my Certified Kubernetes Administrator Exam preparation and didn’t find any suitable study material for preparation. After that I selected Linux Foundation CKA Dumps for my preparation and guess what I am Kubernetes Administrator Certified now. DumpsSchool is a reliable source according to my experience.

Alexandra King said...

i have passed AZ-900 Exam in first attempt by using AZ-900 Dumps Highly Recommended!!

Raima Ali said...

Welcome to most recent Jobs in Pakistan page where you'll handily discover todays vocation alternatives as publicized by various private and government divisions in Pakistan. Here you can track down every one of the most recent reports in regards to occupations. We are a country of youth who are searching for new Job openings. Occupation trackers are welcomed here to secure the positions as per their need. We at beeducated.com attempt to give you all the update rundown of occupations all through Pakistan as quickly as time permits. On the off chance that you take a gander at the accompanying rundown of jobs, you'll see that we keep this page new with most recent occupation jobs in Pakistan from all newspapers occupations, private and governments Sectors postings so you don't miss any update about jobs.

areejes wardrobe said...



Areejas Wardrobe Online Clothing in Pakistan
Areejas Wordobe offers you an exclusive range of infant and toddler clothing online in Pakistan. Visit us now and find baby headbands, baby princess tiaras, baby caps, baby hats, baby hair clips, baby hair bows, etc. all at one place in very affordable prices.

musk al mahal said...

Musk Al Mahal Offers Original Fragrances at Very Reasonable Prices
Musk Al Mahal Perfumery& Cosmetics produces an exclusive range of high-quality Real Attars, Arabian & Western Fragrances. By the Grace of Allah, we are doing creative work and developing new brands every day, under the very competent team of designers, perfumers & chemists, who are empowered with dedication and commitment.

Unknown said...

AG Tile and Stone has been in the tile and stone installation industry for over 30 years. Now serving Upstate SC. Greenville, Anderson and Spartanburg counties. Allow us to assist you in adding style and beauty to your next home residential or commercial project.

harry said...

Captain Dunes is a UAE-based destination management company accredited by the Department of Tourism and Commerce Marketing (DTCM) of the Government of Dubai.

Unknown said...

So, search engine marketing services mainly increases a website’s visibility in the search engine result pages. This paid digital marketing strategy is undoubtedly a treasured tactic for driving high-quality traffic. In this process, the business pays multiple platforms, including Yahoo, Google, etc., to run their advertisements.

Unknown said...

Format Homes is an oriented company in Adelaide who is innovated to provide you with all your interest alongside all the demands and wants. Our home builders offer full ease to each and everyone of our customers in every matter.

EdumpsCollection said...

https://sovipzone.blogspot.com/2011/10/pfizer-facebook-fiasco-chapstick.html?showComment=1631546499648#c6271118314831905034

harry said...

Bobcat designers is a tech-oriented digital marketing solution provider, and we create useful custom strategies for our clients to meet their individual needs. We believe in teamwork, and our company is famous for lead-generating digital marketing solutions. Our team has award-winning marketers, developers, designers, and writers dedicated to providing the best marketing tactics to clients.

harry said...

Voice Overs ordered through voiceoversdirect are considered royalty free. voiceoversdirect will make every attempt possible to ensure your voice recording is delivered in a timely manner.

Jamssmith said...

Proximate SolutionsCaptain Dunes has been delivering digital marketing and eCommerce services. We combine proven methodologies, business domain knowledge and technology expertise of skilled professionals to deliver high-quality solutions. We leverage our large knowledge base to deliver solutions that meet customers’ needs, business, and budget expectations. As a leader in SEO, eCommerce and Internet marketing services, our firm prides itself on driving traffic, converting visitors, and measuring effectiveness to ultimately deliver real scores.

Case Study about SEO said...

Format Homes is one of the pioneer House and Land Packages Adelaide in real estate Agency in Adelaide Australia. We deal in real estate industry from last 15 years and proves our identity with delivered a number of projects.

harry said...

RAWAYAT- Panaché Apparel’s latest collection is the multiple combinations of embroidered patterns and fabrics that are bound to keep you comfortable and stylish ♥️. As the name suggests this collection depicts a wearable piece of poetry, fine tailoring and luxury fabrics, and rich designs which create an aura of elegance and class.

harry said...

"Colorado-Farmed, Owned and Operated. and Trusted Supplier to Customers and Farmers Nationally and Globally
Locally owned by passionate, hard-working and experienced hemp growers who have been in the industry for years, Colorado Breeders Depot (CBD) has rapidly become the preferred source for the best premium smokable hemp flower and wholesale CBD & CBG seeds anywhere on the internet.
We operate out our hemp farm in Canon City, Colorado and do all of our growing and operations on the property, so there is nothing shady or hidden about anything we do."

Unknown said...

Need a custom window boxes for your home, office, or business? Packzy has you covered! We can design a window box that perfectly fits the look of your space, and we’ll make sure it arrives at your doorstep ready to be put into place. You can order free shipping on our website or order custom sized boxes by contacting our sales team.

Hibba Bukhari said...

3 Marla houses in Lahore for sale, buy houses of 3 Marla, 5 Marla, 10 Marla, 1 Kanal, 2 Kanal and more - find from a wide range of houses with Aetmaad.com. We are one of Pakistan's trusted real estate marketing agency in Pakistan, helping you to find apartments, villas, and houses for sale.

Case Study about SEO said...

Web Hosting (also known as Web site hosting, Web hosting, and Webhosting) is the business of housing, serving, and maintaining files for one or more Web sites. More important than the computer space that is provided for Web site files is the fast connection to the Internet.
For more guide follow link: https://navicosoft01.blogspot.com/2022/04/guide-for-complete-web-hosting.html

kabcogroup said...


Thank you for sharing this insightful material. This is a great post. I'm going to periodically visit your blog for some new updates.
General Swimming Pool Contractors in Dubai

harry said...

honey in pakistan, and an important part of every household routine. You can trust us to never let you down with the best honey ever! We offer a single, essential table spoon of pure, organic honey. We believe that honey is an important one-tablespoon essential for a healthy and perfect life.

harry said...

Exandnext website offered to Create a store on this site and add products on this platform and sell your products online easy and anyone easy to purchase any type of product on this Website.

Buying Real Estate in Turkey: A Value Trap? said...

Welcome to OTTOMAN Properties! We are a real estate company that specializes in property management, asset management, real estate brokerage, and more. We have over 30 years of combined experience in the industry, and our team is dedicated to providing our clients with the best possible service. Our asset management division oversees a wide range of properties, from residential to commercial to agricultural. So whether you're interested in buying, selling, or renting, we can help you out. Thanks for choosing OTTOMAN Properties!
www.ottomanpropeties.com

Country Blinds said...

"Country roller shutters mean your home really can can be your castle. Once fully closed, our roller shutters are extremely difficult to penetrate and a major deterrent for would-be burglars.
Country roller shutters! also provide you and your family with total control over the amount of privacy you need from within the comfort of your home both day and night, as well as reducing noise levels by up to 50 percent."

Hucu AI said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
olivia-james said...

Free 300-715 Dumps proved to be my best choice. It is not only free but it gives a stronghold of knowledge about each topic. I went through free 300-715 Real Questions 2023 and was ready to appear in the final IT exam. I am happy that I solved all the questions.

Abufaysal said...

Your blogs are informative and useful keep sharing such good knowledge through your blogs. Also Visit:
Rent a Car in Madinah

harry said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
harry said...

your blog is very informative and useful
thanks for sharing information.
if you interested for latest news visit our website
yimusanfendi
yimusanfendi
yimusanfendi

harry said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
harry said...

your blog is very informative and useful
thanks for sharing information.
if you interested for limousine service visit our website

alexscott said...

"The 200-901 Dumps provided on Realexamdumps for the DevNet Associate (DEVASC) is top-quality. It covers all the important concepts and includes practice questions that challenged me and helped reinforce my understanding. The interactive format made studying engaging, and I felt well-prepared for the exam after using this resource.

Zohaib Ali said...

Welcome to RiteAnswers, your go-to hub for knowledge and essential services that filled your personal and professional growth. Our platform is a treasure trove of expert insights, cutting-edge strategies, and reliable resources across various domains, including business, digital marketing, domain hosting, content marketing, and health.

Post a Comment